So wait, Apple had constructive knowledge of Voip-pal’s lobbying because the lobbying letters were posted on pacer in the litigation docket on May of 2017 – and NOW they are complaining? Talk about being over-entitled. It’s bad enough when companies believe that its OK to lobby ex parte to kill patents, but lobbying ex parte to save patents is bad. But now to complain about the lobbying more than 6 months after that lobbying was publicized in the court docket? Really? Is Apple that spoiled? or am I missing something here.